Oreo Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Truffles

I often joke that I’m a walking advertisement for Costco because I’m always gushing about my latest find or fabulous deal. From their cute greeting cards to their juicy sweet fresh strawberries – I love it all! In fact, I’ve talked about Costco in eleven posts already, and this mention makes it number twelve! When I noticed the Costco Connection magazine features member recipes, I sent in two of my own and look what they published this month! Apparently my Costco karma has come full circle!

To celebrate, I decided to combine two of my favorite things – eggless cookie dough and Oreos. I whipped up a batch of my peanut butter cookie dough and mixed in some leftover Oreos. Then I rolled the dough into truffles and coated the outside of each one in more crushed cookies. Just writing this post is actually making me crave one of these little guys – they are so yummy and completely addicting! The best part is that they are the perfect treat to make on a hot summer day when you don’t want to turn on the oven.

Oreo Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Truffles
Printable Recipe

1/4 cup butter, softened
1/2 cup packed light brown sugar
2 tablespoons milk
1/2 cup creamy peanut butter
1/2 cup plus 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour
1/2 teaspoon salt
14 Oreo cookies

Cream butter and brown sugar in a large bowl. Stir in milk and peanut butter and then gradually beat in flour and salt. Pulse 10 Oreos in the food processor until coarsely chopped and mix into the cookie dough. Roll into 32 1-inch spheres. Pulse remaining 4 cookies in food processor until finely ground and coat truffles in the crushed cookies. Makes 32 truffles.

Nutrition: 82 calories, 5.0g fat, 0.4g fiber, 1.5g protein per truffle
Cost: $0.10 per truffle

Page 1 of 11

36 Responses to Oreo Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Truffles

  1. peachkins says:

    OMG! I’m on a diet…I shouldn’t have dropped by.. i’m so craving for one of these…

  2. Lauren says:

    Congrats on the article Kerstin! The salmon sounds delish. Then there’s those oreo peanut butter cookie dough truffles… oh my. You managed to combine three of my favorite things in one little package! They sound absolutely amazing :).

  3. Joanne says:

    Congrats on your Costco feature! I have both a BJ’s AND a Costco membership (overkill much?) so yeah I know what you mean about singing their praises.

    These truffles look downright amazing. What a great way to celebrate!

  4. dani says:

    recipe looks great. congrats :)

  5. Michelle says:

    Congratulations! That is such a great accomplishment!

  6. Sophie says:

    Congrats on being published with one of your lovely recipes!! yeah to you!!

    Enjoy the fame even more with these tasty treats!

  7. Sinful little balls!! nom nom nom

  8. Elina says:

    Yay, so exciting. I asked my parents to pick up a copy next time they’re in the store (they already tossed the one they received in the mail :( ).
    I want these little balls. Yum! :D

  9. Cara says:

    Congrats, Kerstin! And those truffles sound like the perfect way to celebrate too :)

  10. so fun that you got published! these truffles are adorable!!!!

  11. Katrina says:

    Congrats on the spot in the Costco paper. Full circle would mean they’re paying you. ;)
    The truffles look killer. Do you think they’d freeze well? I’m trying to make lots of treats (ahead of time) for a family reunion coming up.

  12. Louise says:

    Well, it looks like another congratulations is coming your way. Way cool…

    As for those delectable peanut butter delights of yours, holy goodness. They look just gorgeous.

    Thank you so much for sharing…

  13. Shannon says:

    how cool!!! that is a perfect thing to celebrate, and these truffles certainly do it justice :)

  14. L'Chicken says:

    I love it!! I am a total Costco FREAK– I don’t know how I didn’t pick up on your similar affection in past posts. That is so cool that you are in the Costco ‘zine. Seriously– that’s major celebrity status in my world. You just keep giving me more and more reasons to dig your style, Kerstin…

  15. Monica H says:

    Ha! I was coming over here to tell you that I just saw this in the COstco Connection today! woot!

    In fact, I was at aork and my boss had clipped this recipe and it was sitting on the kitchen counter. I thought it was Rachael Ray and I picked it up and read it and saw it was you and said “hey I know her!”

    You’re just too cool for words :-) Oh and I LOVE Costco too.

  16. grace says:

    that’s definitely cause for celebration–congrats! and what a way to honor the occasion–these couldn’t be more delectable. the end. :)

  17. Congrats on your publication! Those little truffles look toooooo goood!

  18. CaSaundra says:

    Congrats on being in the magazine–the recipe they published sounds delish, as do these truffles. Yum!

  19. Laura says:

    Congrats! That’s very cool :)

  20. Blond Duck says:

    You’re famous now!

  21. Congrats Kerstin! And these truffles look amazing too! :)

  22. Lucie says:

    I think I just screamed with delight when I saw these. Congratulations on the article!!!

  23. Amanda says:

    Congratulations, Kerstin! The oreo truffles look delicious…chocolate & peanut butter is my kind of dessert.

    I’m getting married in a week and wondered if you had any great, classic recipes to whip up for my future husband. I love to bake and he loves to cook, but I want to surprise my new hubby with a delicious dinner! You have so many unique recipes, I thought I’d ask your opinion!

  24. Sues says:

    That’s awesome!! I love that they put a big photo of you too :) My sister makes some fabulous Oreo truffles, but adding peanut butter to the mix? Best idea ever!!

  25. ingrid says:

    VERY cool! We had a membership to Costco but found ourselves more often at Sam’s. My honey loves that place.

  26. yasmeen says:

    Delectable treats.I’m a regular at costco,congrats on the publish :D

  27. terri says:

    hang on while i wipe the drool off my chin! i love cookie dough, but i LOVE peanut butter! i have to make these…..NOW!

  28. Thanks to all!

    Elina – Thanks!!

    Katrina – Haha, that’s what my mom said too :)

    Monica – Aww, what a cute story!

    Amanda – I hope you have a wonderful wedding! This is my hubby’s favorite: http://cakebatterandbowl.com/goat-cheese-risotto-with-yellow-squash-and-zucchini.html

  29. Janis says:

    CONGRATS! I was reading your blog and just happend to have the costco connection next to me. I see your recipe! Awesome! :) I also LOVE costco and buy the salmon all the time. I actually have it in my fridge right now. Did you just send the recipe to the connection? I’d love to give some of my recipes a try for print.

  30. Nicole, RD says:

    Those sound evil! But only 82 calories evil? I can handle that :) I think I’ve had something similar, just made with cream cheese. I’ll have to make these!

  31. HOw fun that they posted your recipe!
    I have crazy Costco love too…it’s an issue!
    These truffles look so great, love the chocolate and pb combo :)

  32. Congratulations on having your recipe published! And, peanut butter truffles sound delicious.

  33. Meghan says:

    Oh my gosh – it’s so cool that you are in the Costco magazine! You are famous!

    I always love your truffles. My sister just got engaged and wants to use some of your truffles as her wedding favors!

  34. [...] want any hard pieces of chocolate getting in the way. As you probably know, playing with eggless cookie dough is one of my favorite past times, so if you try these, the trick to getting perfectly [...]

  35. Ruth says:

    I made these truffles because I had oodles of oreos and the ingredients lying around. They are AMAZING. I shared them with my neighbors and their kids and they went wild. I could only eat one myself because I am a diabetic, but soooo tasty. I have to say though, they don’t look too good before you roll them in the oreo crumbs. XD But a wonderful recipe! Thank you!

  36. Ruth – Yay, so glad you and your neighbors enjoyed them :) Thanks for taking the time to comment and let me know!

Leave a reply