Strawberry Cheesecake Filled Yellow Cake

Have you had any baking disasters? I’ve had my fair share, and naturally, they all tend to occur when I’m making a treat to share at a party. One time the pecan crust just fell off the sides of a cheesecake I had made for a lab birthday celebration. Another time a cake I made for a dinner party that was loaded with peach puree, didn’t taste like peaches at all, which would have been ok, except that I had just announced it was a peach cake! And I wince every time I think about the night I was easing a cake out of its pan onto a cooling rack and the pan slipped away from me and fell onto a different cake layer that was already cooling – that cake split into 4 pieces, eeek (I ended up pressing all the chunks together like puzzle pieces and making it the bottom layer and I don’t think anyone noticed, thankfully!). Creating new recipes is just so fun though that I usually can’t bring myself to repeat a dessert that I know always turns out well, so I take a bit of a chance each time and the hope that if anything goes wrong, that I’ll be able to save my dessert with a bit of creativity. Enter this cake.

Jen recently posted a beautiful carrot cake with a cheesecake filling that I thought was just genius. She was inspired to put the cheesecake layer in the center of the cake after seeing Erin’s mouth watering Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake and Peanut Butter Cheesecake Cake. When my undergrad assistant Juliana’s birthday rolled around, she told me her favorite desserts were cheesecake with fruit topping and light yellow cake, so I was inspired by Jen and Erin to combine the two desserts into one marvelous treat. Everything went well at first. I baked up a layer of strawberry cheesecake two days before the celebration and then made the tender yellow cakes the night before. They stacked up nicely, but things quickly went downhill when I began to work on the strawberry cream cheese frosting I had dreamed up. I forgot to put the butter in and when I added some strawberry preserves it became a runny mess. When I realized it was beyond saving and that I was out of powdered sugar, cream cheese, and heavy cream, I started racking my brain for a quick frosting fix since the last thing I wanted to do was head out to the store at 12:30am!

I ended up hesitantly stirring up a box of instant vanilla pudding with a little milk and a few cups of Chobani Strawberry Greek Yogurt. It had a lovely light texture but was still thick enough to adhere to the cake! I added in some strawberry preserves for a little extra strawberry punch, frosted my cake, and fell into bed. Will this experience stop me from attempting new desserts the day before I need them? Nope, of course not!

Strawberry Cheesecake Filled Yellow Cake
Printable Recipe

Ingredients:

Cheesecake:
3 cups pureed strawberries (I pulsed 30 ounces strawberries in the food processor)
24 ounces cream cheese, at room temperature
1 cup granulated sugar
3 large eggs, at room temperature
1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Yellow Cake:
3 cups cake flour
2 teaspoons baking soda
1 teaspoon salt
1 cup unsalted butter, at room temperature
1 1/2 cups granulated sugar
4 large eggs, at room temperature
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 1/2 cups buttermilk

Strawberry Frosting and Garnish:
1 3.4-ounce package instant vanilla pudding
1/4 cup milk
2 6-ounce containers Chobani Nonfat Strawberry Greek Yogurt
1/2 cup low sugar strawberry preserves
10 ounces strawberries, sliced

Directions:
To make the cheesecake layer, heat oven to 350˚F. Place strawberry puree in a small nonstick pan over medium low heat and heat for 25 minutes, stirring occasionally, or until reduced to 1 cup. Let cool to room temperature. Combine the cream cheese and sugar in a large bowl and beat on medium-high speed with a mixer for 3 minutes or until smooth. Beat in the eggs one at a time, mixing well after each addition and scraping down the sides of the bowl as needed. Blend in vanilla and cooled strawberry puree. Pour into a greased 9-inch springform pan lined with parchment paper and bake at 350˚F for 60 minutes or until edges are set and middle is slightly wobbly. Cool to room temperature, about one hour. Place in the refrigerator for several hours or until chilled.

To make the cake, heat the oven to 350˚F. Mix together flour, baking soda, and salt and sift the mixture into a large bowl. Beat butter and sugar with a mixer in a large bowl until creamed. Add in eggs and vanilla extract and mix until smooth. Slowly mix in half the flour mixture, followed by half the buttermilk, until smooth. Repeat with remaining flour and buttermilk. Pour batter into two greased 8-inch cake pans lined with parchment paper. Bake cakes at 350˚F for 30 to 35 minutes or until a toothpick in the center comes out clean and the tops are light golden brown. Cool for 5 minutes in the pan and then run a knife around the edges of each cake. Flip over onto wire racks and cool cakes completely, about an hour.

To make the strawberry frosting, place vanilla pudding and milk in a large bowl and whisk until well combined. Stir in yogurt and strawberry preserves. Chill in the refrigerator 5 minutes or until thickened.

To assemble the cake, place one layer of the yellow cake on a serving platter. Remove cheesecake from the pan and flip over on top of the yellow cake. Cut around the edges of the cheesecake layer so it fits the cake layer. Place second layer of yellow cake on top. Evenly cover with strawberry frosting and garnish with strawberries. Makes 20 servings.

Nutrition: 438 calories, 23.4g fat, 1.6g fiber, 9.2g protein per serving
Cost: $0.90 per serving

43 Responses to Strawberry Cheesecake Filled Yellow Cake

  1. Ha ha. I feel the same way. I’d rather try out something new than repeat a dessert. Sometimes it can be a bit trying, but it’s always really fun to show up with something new and exciting.

    I love when bloggers are inspired by other bloggers! The cake look beautiful!

  2. Oh cake disasters. How I love/hate thee! LOVE because they end up with delicious frostings like this out of crazy ingredients. (And hate them because sometimes I end up with butter and powdered sugar clumped in my hair and broken cake everywhere.)

    • ps- I’m a horrible baker and every time I go to bake something, I usually have an epic disaster. Your cheesecake I made a few months ago was so successful and it made me feel like I can do this! Even with your problems- it seems you were quite the problem solver and the cake looks delicious.

  3. Haha, I always seem to have similar experiences with baking for people (which may explain why I don’t do it often). Glad you were able to whip the frosting up, and it sounds (and looks) delicious!

  4. ha, all of your ‘disasters’ aren’t really disasters :) but love how you saved the frosting! and it looks awesome… mmm, strawberries!!!

  5. I wish all my flops looked as pretty as yours! Although, I hardly call this one a flop. So the cheesecake layer didn’t try to sink into the cake? That’s what I was afraid you were going to say. This looks delicious! Isn’t it fun to search through your fridge and pantry to try to find magic ingredients?!

  6. I love that you are so creative to fix a baking mistake. I am so nervous about baking that when things like that happen…I often don’t know how to fix things!

  7. Glad it all turned out well. Looking at the picture, I think otherwise no one would have been the wiser that it was not your intent. I will say, it’s nice to know that others have these human moments. I think as bloggers we often tend to talk only of the successes so it can seem like our peers are all super human with not a single fault to their name. So yes, I’ve had baking challenges myself and though I wouldn’t wish them on anyone, it does make me feel good to know I’m not the only one. Is it terrible to say that!?!

  8. It’s seriously the story of my life that I have baking disasters whenever I’m baking something for a special event/person. But I LOVE trying new things for events because then my baking actually has a purpose.

    Your save was awesome! I think it’s beautiful… And especially considering it was 12:30 a.m… I’m totally impressed!

  9. Despite your frosting problem the cake looks incredibly good Kerstin! Good save! I would of never thought to do that. The cheesecake in the middle is genius!

  10. It is quite beautiful and I never would have guessed you had issues with this cake. What a lucky birthday girl. Vanilla cheesecake between 2 layers of strawberry cake- I’d love that too!

  11. Wow Kerstin, I love the idea of filling cake with cheesecake…what I lovely cake it turned out to be. Nice of you baking a cake for your assistant on her birthday…hope you are having a great week :-)

  12. Thanks everyone! Luckily, there’s a market open 24 hours by us, so I wasn’t too worried if my experiment didn’t turn out, but it would have been such a pain to have to go to the store!

    Danielle – Nope, the layers were baked separately, which is key I think.

    Michelle – It’s just practice!

    Kelly – Yeah, I think everyone has frustrating moments in the kitchen, even the bloggers that pretend to be perfect :)

  13. oh heck yes! I’ve had cookies turn into runny pancakes in the oven, used a tablespoon instead of a teaspoon of baking powder…all kinds of fun! This cake is GORGEOUS! A happy accident I would say :)

  14. I remember Jen’s carrot cake that I thought was genius and I’m sure incredibly delicious. Yours sounds amazing as well and it sounds like you totally saved the day with the yogurt/pudding trick. I would have freaked :)

  15. Whenever I bake a cake from scratch it normally turns out really super dry..and I was wondering if there is any trick to make it nice and moist. By the way your cake looks beautiful,and I am going to try this recipe out for my boyfriends birthday.

  16. Hi Nicole – Do you have an oven thermometer? Your oven may be running hot so you could be over-baking them. I always check on cakes 10 minutes before the time estimates in recipes as well. It’s also important to measure your flour correctly because if you add too much that can also make it dry. I always gently scoop mine into the cup with a spoon. I hope it turns out well for you!

  17. This cake looks amazing… I’m going to make it for my brother’s birthday this weekend. I can’t wait to see how it turns out. :)

Leave a reply

Pinterest
Email
Print